The
Edge - 02/02/2001
Joining the fray
Lee Chui Yu
Jacqueline Tai
and her board of directors will be breaking new ground when they
open their financial portal for membership sometime soon. AlphaInvestmentBank.com
will be the first home-grown version of First Tuesday on the Net,
and, they claim, the first in Asia to offer virtual open-ended one-stop
financial services.
Going by the success of franchised Internet networking event First
Tuesday and the proliferation of me-too events in Malaysia in the
past year, Tai and partners may have yet another success story to
tell. After all, investors still have money to spend on deserving
start-ups and there will always be people looking for funding for
a good idea.
But the road to success may not be without obstacles, as many struggling
dotcom companies looking for that elusive pot of gold have learned.
For one thing, the portal will have to compete -- either indirectly
or directly -- with other more established portals like CocoonAsia.com
and IandIAsia.com. In addition, it will have to contend with an
industry that, despite being focused on technology, still very much
likes to do business the old-fashioned way -- through face-to-face
transactions.
Still, Tai -- the portal's managing director and a merchant banker
by profession -- is unfazed. She says: "Competition is always healthy.
As in any other business, (I believe) there should always be more
than one player."
She believes AlphaInvestmentBank.com is different as it offers more
than what is available in the Asian market, and thus does not have
any competition. "Looking at similar websites in Asia, they don't
prepare or provide (our) kind of resources. We're not afraid to
share (information)," she adds.
"Those portals in the West are not ready to receive investors outside
the US. As it is, their priority is to cater to their own market."
In addition to matching start-up entrepreneurs with investors, venture
capitalists and angels, AlphaInvestmentBank.com will also provide
a platform for buyers to directly access sellers of private equity
businesses to enable mergers and acquisitions as well as joint-venture
transactions. With this, Tai and her partners strongly believe that
AlphaInvestmentBank.com will fill a long-neglected niche in the local
and regional investment market.
"This idea of having an open-ended portal is only two years old.
It's proven to be a successful model in the US and fills a need.
(For,) overnight, you're exposed to people whom you don't know.
(Thus) the probability of being successful is much bigger," she
explains.
"There is a need (in Malaysia). Here, it is public knowledge that
small- and medium-sized industries (SMI) are crying out for help
and seeking alternative sources of funding. We created the portal
to meet this need."
Apart from its open-ended system, AlphaInvestmentBank.com counts
its accessibility, a big resource library, strong partnerships and
its affordability among its strengths. It costs nothing to place
a listing on the site and for those who want more privileges, like
the ability to browse and search, the annual fee is US$100 per individual
and US$295 per corporate membership. InvestmentBank Asia. com, which
boasts a comprehensive databank of Asean banks, financial institutions,
stockbroking firms and insurance companies, promises to give users
access to tools and resourceful research information to help investors
invest and entrepreneurs to build and sell their business.
Tai says InvestmentBankAsia. com ensures that both entrepreneurs
and investors are bona fide, and that the approval process is stringent.
"The Malaysian venture capital industry is not regulated. So in
our website, we have set our own benchmarks (a RM10 million ceiling
to be an approved investor and RM500,000 for individuals)," she
elaborates.
In addition, InvestmentBankAsia.
com -- owned by Digital Hub Sdn Bhd, which is privately owned by
Tai and her partners -- is part of 3exchanges.com. The portal is
a joint venture with the Multimedia Development Corporation's Agensi
Pekerjaan KWX Sdn Bhd, which owns kwxasia.com, a human resources
recruitment and training centre, as well as ideasasia.com, a virtual
incubator. (Ideasasia is also owned by Digital and is expected to
be ready in May.)
Tai says 3exchanges.com has already been accepted by countries in
the Asean region and 54 Commonwealth member countries. It is also
negotiating with 10 Scandinavian countries.
This week, Tai and partners will go to Hanoi to present their business
model, in the start of an extensive two-month international road
show. The objective? To bring in 61 country partners to Kuala Lumpur
for a conference by June.
Going by the feedback on AlphaInvestmentBank.com from some entrepreneurs
and investors contacted by The Edge, Tai and her team have their
work cut out for them.
As yet, it has no members, and has little to show.
The main reason for the scepticism, most industry players say, is
that they prefer face-to-face dealings. Most say they would only
use the portal to "improve their chances".
"Too many people have come up with concepts similar to this," notes
a technology entrepreneur who requested anonymity. "The way I prefer
to do it is face to face. That's because it's personal and you can
show the VCs how committed you are. With a lot of portals, it's
fog and mirrors without substantiation; so I'll be cautious for
now."
He adds: "The VC industry is very much like a meat market. I always
believe that if you have a solid business idea, people will come
to you. If you keep hawking your products and nobody is investing
in it, then it's a bad sign."
An investment broker echoes this view. "I guess the selling point
for this is that it's free, so it wouldn't cost anything to set
up there," he notes.
"It's an attractive idea but the investment community is very small.
Among non-local VCs, there is a feeling of caution, so a lot of
these guys will only look at referrals. On the other side, many
high-net-worth investors won't just go online to look for opportunities,"
he adds.
Still, Tai and her partners are confident. Plans for the future
are vague, with Tai only willing to go as far as to say that InvestmentBank
Asia.com's progress will follow that of other dotcoms -- it will
seek venture capital in the near future and its ultimate destination
will be a listing within the next few years.
Growth will come from strategic alliances. Although it is looking
for new partners, it is still unsure of whom and what form the partnerships
will take, only that it will expand to the 10 Asean countries, then
the rest of Asia and then "westwards", says Tai.
So that membership will reach 10,000 in the first year, the company
will allocate about 10 to 20 per cent of its turnover to advertising
and promotions. The bulk of this will be on promoting and presenting
the portal, which has a paid-up capital of RM500,000, to SMI associations
and individuals within these associations.
But for now, Tai and her partners will bank on their brick-and-mortar
business -- corporate finance consultancy work -- to bring in the
moolah.
Digital Hub's board members include Calvin Goh, a merchant banker
and Robert A Young, a structural engineer by profession.
|